Reponse to 'The logic of effective altruism'

Abstract

Effective altruism, while ostensibly a noble pursuit, may have unforeseen consequences. This article argues that assigning to individuals and groups roles typically reserved for societal institutions, such as providing health care or upholding justice, can erode trust in the state and make it difficult to develop state capacity in other crucial areas. Moreover, the article argues that precise measurement of the social value of a donated dollar is impossible, and that the focus on maximizing impact may lead to a narrow view of social value, diverting resources from political factors that underpin long-term economic development. Finally, the article suggests that the emphasis on maximizing earnings to give more could influence what society views as a meaningful life. – AI-generated abstract