The problem of being
In William James (ed.) Some problems of philosophy, London, 1911, pp. 38–46
Abstract
The fundamental metaphysical inquiry concerns why a world exists instead of a nonentity. Reflection on this problem reveals that the non-existence of the universe is as conceivable as its presence, yet the transition from nothingness to being lacks a logical bridge. Various philosophical traditions attempt to resolve this mystery by either dismissing the question as illegitimate or asserting the necessity of existence. Rationalist perspectives often posit that absolute perfection implies existence, while evolutionary empiricists suggest that the simplest forms of reality emerged first to bridge the gap from non-existence. However, these attempts fail to provide a reasoned solution. Whether existence is viewed as an eternal regress or an absolute beginning, the presence of reality must ultimately be assumed as a given. The paradoxes of infinite time and the failure of mathematical or logical identities to account for facticity suggest that existence is a contingent datum. Consequently, philosophy cannot burrow beneath the fact of being to find a prior cause; it must instead accept existence as a primal gift and focus on describing its nature rather than explaining its origin. – AI-generated abstract.